Homepage
[60%] 
For those of you who don't know, Maydie and Pat are two famous Rank 14 warriors from the pre-Burning Crusade era.
Grand Marshal Maydie's Video
High Warlord Pat's Video
There are several reasons for me to believe that Maydie is superior.
-Racials. Pat had his racial stun and +5% stamina bonus. Maydie had a boost to perception, which isn't worth much because he would beat rogues to a pulp in no time flat.
-Pocket Healers. Maydie and Pat both had pocket healers. If I'm not mistaken, Pat had more.
-Shaman advantage. Pat can be seen kicking ass, but with the aid of a Windfury Totem, which at that time applied the Windfury buff to the party member's weapons. In addition, Pat had Sword Specialization and the Hand of Justice trinket. In theory:
1 swing + 1 windfury = 3 + Hand of Justice + Windfury = 7 + Sword Specialization + Windfury = 10 swings in one hit, 6 with extra attack power. If this was at the time of the windfury bug, then the possible number would rise to 30. DAMN.
-Gear advantage. Pat was one of the first High Warlords. The people he fought were scrubs. The highest-rank HK I've seen him get was a Field Marshal - Maydie got several High Warlord kills in his video.
Any more reasons I think up will be added.
So tell me. Who do you think is better?
Grand Marshal Maydie's Video
High Warlord Pat's Video
There are several reasons for me to believe that Maydie is superior.
-Racials. Pat had his racial stun and +5% stamina bonus. Maydie had a boost to perception, which isn't worth much because he would beat rogues to a pulp in no time flat.
-Pocket Healers. Maydie and Pat both had pocket healers. If I'm not mistaken, Pat had more.
-Shaman advantage. Pat can be seen kicking ass, but with the aid of a Windfury Totem, which at that time applied the Windfury buff to the party member's weapons. In addition, Pat had Sword Specialization and the Hand of Justice trinket. In theory:
1 swing + 1 windfury = 3 + Hand of Justice + Windfury = 7 + Sword Specialization + Windfury = 10 swings in one hit, 6 with extra attack power. If this was at the time of the windfury bug, then the possible number would rise to 30. DAMN.
-Gear advantage. Pat was one of the first High Warlords. The people he fought were scrubs. The highest-rank HK I've seen him get was a Field Marshal - Maydie got several High Warlord kills in his video.
Any more reasons I think up will be added.
So tell me. Who do you think is better?
